Advances in molecular aspects of antagonists have paved the way of creating improved biological control agents (iBCA). Induction of random mutations by physical mutagens such as UV, X, gamma radiation and chemical mutagens such as ethylmethane sulfonate have been used as useful tools to manipulate antagonists genetically (1, 2). Several studies have shown that gamma-ray radiation can cause genetic diversity of filamentous fungi and induce positive (3, 4 and 5) or negative mutants (6) of specific genes. Trichoderma species are filamentous fungi with teleomorphs belonging to the Hypocreales order of the Ascomycota. A number of potential biocontrol agents within the genus of Trichoderma have been reported that can act against soilborne plant pathogens, including T. harzianum (7). Several researchers have studied the enhancement of some metabolic functions such as secretion of extracellular cell wall-degrading enzymes and antibiotic production of mycoparasite Trichoderma isolates after a treatment by physical mutagens (8, 9, 10, 5 and 11).
In situ identification of superior biocontrol isolate of Trichoderma was achieved by using Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA (RAPD) (12), Sequence Characterized Ampilfied Regions (SCAR) markers (13) and real-time PCR (14). Rep-PCR is the genomic fingerprinting method that is based on the use of DNA primers corresponding to naturally occurring interspersed repetitive elements in bacteria, such as the REP, ERIC and BOX elements and has been used to evaluate genetic diversity and distinguish strains in bacteria (15). This method has also been used for evaluation of genetic diversity of fungi including Fusarium oxysporum (16), Verticillium chlamydosporium (6) Leptosphaeria maculans (20), Macrophomina phaseolina (19), Rhizoctonia solani (20, 21) and Tilletia spp. (24); so far this method has not been applied for evaluation of genetic diversity in biocontrol isolates of Trichoderma species.
Random gamma radiation with optimal dose (a dose at which near 50% of spores was abled to germinate) was applied on T. harzianum. Phenotypic alterations (antagonistic activities against some soil borne fungal pathogens) and genotype of gamma induced mutants were compared with WT via RAPD and rep-PCR (23, 24).
3. Materials and Methods
3.1. Culture of Microorganisms
T. harzianum was isolated from soil rhizosphere of healthy plants (Beta vulgaris) adjacent to or between two wilted plants in Khuzestan province, using dilution plate technique on Trichoderma selective medium (TSM) (25) and purified by single spore culture. The isolates were identified on the basis of their morphological characteristics (26). The purified and identified cultures of T. harzianum were maintained on Potato Dextrose Agar (PDA) medium and stored at 4ºC for further use. Soilborne fungal plant pathogens including F. graminearum (Fusarium head blight of wheat), S. sclerotiorum (Sclerotinia stem rot of canola), M. phaseolina (charcoal rot of melon) and R. solani AG4 (melon damping-off) were received from the Culture Collection of the Tarbiat Modares University.
3.2. T. harzianum dose Assessmentand Mutants Isolation
Spore suspension (107 mL-1) of T. harzianum 65 (Th65) isolate (WT) was spread on Water-Agar (WA) plates then irradiated with gammacell (Co- 60, activity 2500 Curry, rate dose of 0.23 Gy.second-1 by doses of 0, 50, 150, 200, 250, 300, 350, 400 and 450 Gy at Nuclear Science and Technology Research Institute of Iran and incubated at 25ºC for 7 days. The irradiated spores of each dose were transformed to PDA plates by a needle. After 24 h, percentage of germinated spores was recorded (24).
3.3. Antagonistic Activity Assay Against 4 Soilborne Phytopathogens
Mutants (24) selected and Th65 (WT) were evaluated in vitro against four soil borne phytopathogens into dual culture described by Dennis and Webster (27). Culture filtrates (extracellular extract or non-volatile compounds) were tested according to Dennis and Webster (28). The mutants and Th65 (WT) were inoculated in conical flasks (250 mL) containing 100 mL potato dextrose broth. Inoculated flasks were incubated at 23±1ºC at 70 rpm for 12 days. The culture was filtered through Micropore filter (0.22 mm, Syringe®) and culture filtrate was added to PDA at 42ºC to obtain a final concentration of 10% (v/v). The medium was poured into the 9 cm plates with 15 mL.plate-1. The medium was inoculated with 7 mm discs of above mentioned pathogens and control plates with no inoculation. The plates were sealed with Parafilm tape and incubated at 27±1ºC, except for S. sclerotiorum that incubated at 23ºC for three days (Figure 1). Pathogens’ GI% were calculated as GI%=(dc-dt)/dc×100, where dc is colony diameter of pathogen in control, and dt is colony diameter of pathogen in treatment. The experiments were conducted in completely randomized design with three replicates and analyzed by SAS (version 9.1). The means were compared with Duncan’s Multiple Range Test (P < 0.05).
3.4. Biomass Production and DNA Extraction
From edges of a 3-day old fungal culture, 3-4 pieces were transferred to flat bottles with 50 mL of Potato Dextrose Broth (PDB) and placed at 25ºC for 48 h at 125 rpm. Mycelia were harvested on filter paper (Whatman No.1) by vacuum pump and stored at -70ºC for further use. DNA extraction was performed as previously described by Safaie et al. (29). Quality and quantity of extracted DNA were assessed by electrophoresis on 0.8% agarose gel and biophotometer (Eppendorf, Germany), respectively.
3.5. Randomly Amplified Polymorphic DNA (RAPD) Analysis
The polymerase chain reactions (PCRs) were carried out in 20 mL of master mix containing 20 ng of genomic DNA template and 10 pmols of random primer (Table 1) (Sinaclon, Iran). All PCR reactions were started at 92ºC for 3 min and 30 cycles of 92ºC:1 min; 33ºC: (except for 35ºC for OPA09) 1 min; and 72ºC: 2 min. The cycles were followed by single cycle of 5 min at 72ºC in an epgradient thermocycler (Eppendorf, Germany). Each reaction of RAPD-PCR repeated twice.
3.6. Repetitive Sequence-based PCR (rep-PCR) Analysis
PCR reaction was carried out in 20 mL and in an epgradient thermocycler (Eppendorf, Germany). The master mix included: 2 mL of buffer (10× PCR buffer) 0.5 mL Taq Polymerase (5 unit.mL-1), 0.8 mL (0.5 mM) MgCl2, 0.4 mL mixture of nucleotides (10 mM), 1 mL (10 pM) of each primer (Table 1) and 1 mL (20 ng) template DNA. In negative control 1 mL of sterile deionized water was added instead of DNA. Thermal cycles were set up with some modifications as described by McDonald et al. (22). For rep-PCR initial at the PCR was initiated at 94ºC for 7 min, followed by 35 (for rep 1R-I) and 40 (for rep 2I) cycles of 92ºC: 1 min; 43ºC (for rep 1R-I) and 40 (for rep 2I):1 min; 72ºC: 2 min. Final extension was 10 min at 72ºC. For BOX-PCR initial denaturation was 94ºC for 3 min that followed by 30 cycles of 94ºC: 1 min; 53ºC: 1 min; 65ºC: 2 min. These cycles were followed by single cycle at 65ºC for 8 min. For ERIC-PCR initial denaturation was at 95ºC for 2 min and 35 cycles of [94ºC:1 min; 51ºC: 1 min; 72ºC: 2 min]. These cycles were followed by single cycle at 72ºC for 7 min. The PCR products and 1 kb ladder were separated on 1.4% (w/v) agarose gel. The bands were visualized by staining with ethidium bromide (1 mg.mL-1) on UV transluminator and data were analyzed using the MVSP software (with Jaccard coefficient).
4.1. Mutagenesis and Isolation of T. harzianum 65 Mutants
Dose of 450 Gy completely (100%) inhibited spore germination. At 250 Gy, 40-50% (43.4%) of spores germinated and therefore was selected as the optimum dose for irradiation (data obtained for the other doses not shown). Mutants (115) were obtained from WT (Th65) and were all tested for growth inhibition against R. solani (data not shown). Accordingly, 24 mutants were selected. The gamma radiation caused differences in morphological properties of T. harzianum such as color, colony appearance, sporulation and growth rate of mycelia at different irradiation. Th1, Th5, Th6 and Th8 mutants had more sporulation in comparison to WT and Th17 showed less after five days of incubation (data not shown).
4.2. In vitro Assays
The GI% of S. sclerotiorum, F. graminearum, M. phaseolina and R. solani AG4 after 3 days of incubation with culture filtrate in dual culture (Tables 2-5) revealed significant differences among mutants and WT (p < 0.05). In between, Th15 showed maximum GI%. Other superior mutants were Th11, Th1 and Th22. Assay of antagonistic activity against F. graminearum revealed that Th11, Th22, Th2, Th15 and Th17 caused more GI% than WT (Table 2). Antagonistic assay against R. solani revealed that Th17, Th9, Th11, Th1 and Th21 resulted in more GI% than WT (Table 3). In vitro assay against S. sclerotiorum revealed that Th5, Th4, Th11 and Th22 had more GI% than WT (Table 4). In vitro assay against M. phaseolina revealed that Th1, Th11, Th15 and Th18 had maximum GI% (Table 5). The maximum GI% by mutant culture filtrates were recorded in S. sclerotiorum (Table 4). In dual culture test, Th4, Th5, Th9, Th11, Th15 and Th17 demonstrated maximum GI% against studied pathogens. Th1, Th4, Th9, Th11, Th15 and Th18 showed more colonization rate than WT after 3 days of incubation with mentioned phytopathogens (data not shown). Culture filtrate tests of Th1, Th2, Th11, Th15 and Th22 showed maximum GI% against studied pathogens (Figures 2 to 5).
4.3. RAPD Analysis
Cluster analysis of RAPD amplicons using 5 random primers revealed a significant genetic diversity between the mutants and WT. OPA010, OPA011, OPA016, OPA09 and OPA014 were managed to amplify 19, 22, 22, 21 and 21 loci, respectively. The percentage of polymorphic bands detected with these primers, were 57.8, 50, 50, 61.9 and 47.6%, respectively. The most amplified loci belonged to OPA011 and OPA016 (Figure 2). DNA fingerprinting using RAPD-PCR revealed that gamma radiation induced genetic changes (Figure 2). The result obtained for combination of five primers of RAPD at similarity level of 84% divided the mutants and WT into 3 groups where the wild type and the Th9 and Th17 mutants were grouped in two separate clades and the rest of mutants in a group in close distance to mutants (Figure 3).
4.4. Rep-PCR Analysis
rep-PCR primers (5) with a similarity of 84% divided the mutants and WT into 3 groups: the group of WT, Th9 and Th17 in a group and the other mutants in other group. The mutants with improved antagonistic activity, Th9 and Th17, separated from WT, in a distinct group (Figure 5). The results obtained for cluster analysis of 5 primers of rep-PCR and DNA fingerprinting revealed that gamma mutation induced genetic changes (Figure 4). Number of identified loci included for REP1R-I, REP2I, Box, ERIC2I and ERIC1 were 26, 23, 15, 21 and 21, respectively and the percentage of polymorphic bands detected in these primers were 73.70, 56.5, 53.3, 61.9 and 66.6%. rep1R-I produced the highest number of loci (Figure 4A). Rep-PCR revealed more polymorphic bands than RAPD-PCR.
Gamma rays have very high energy, causing gene mutations by replacement of nucleotides (by oxidative deamination) or chromosome breakage. Here, random mutation by gamma irradiation with optimal dose of 250 Gy on T. harzianum caused changes in the genome and induced some mutants with more growth and sporulation rates than WT, with improved antagonistic activity for some such as Th1 mutant. Th15, Th11 and Th1 exhibited greater GI% and colonization rate on F. graminearum, S. sclerotiorum, M. phaseolina and R. solani AG4 compared to WT. The obtained data on dual culture tests of isolates like that of culture filtrate assays indicated gamma radiation significantly affected production of extracellular compounds and enzymes involved in mycoparasitism. These secreted molecules led to high antagonistic activities against pathogens in some mutants; some of which showed good performance in dual culture test. However, some others such as Th5 demonstrated weak secretion of enzymes in culture filtrate test. Phenotypically, some other mutants demonstrated improved extracellular secretion, while their colonizations in dual culture were slow.
Induction of mutation is a genetic manipulation method to improve efficacy of biocontrol agents against soil borne plant pathogens (30). Szekeres et al. (31) reported that T. harzianum treated with UV overproduced protease, leading to much biocontrol activity against soil borne fungal phytopathogens. Similarly, Vaidya et al. (32) UV radiated Alcaligenes xylosoxydans produced more chitinase with enhanced biocontrol activity against soil borne fungal pathogens.
The DNA fingerprinting managed to distinguish between mutants and WT with well-coherency with their antagonistic capabilities similar to earlier works (33, 34, 35 and 36).
Among the RAPD primers used, OPA010 amplified a reproducible 500 bp band that separated Th17 from Th9 and other mutants and WT (Figure 2A). According to in vitro assays (Tables 2-5) GIs% of Th9 and Th17 in dual culture tests were similar, but Th9 showed more colonization and growth rate than Th17. Furthermore, in culture filtrate assays Th9 showed higher GI% than Th17, probably this band is related to gene(s) that affects expression of special mycoparasitic enzymes that needs further analysis. Dendrogram of cluster analysis of RAPD (OPA010) separated Th9 from Th17 with 96% coefficient (Figure 3). Zymand et al. (37) used RAPD and identified T-39 of T. harzianum. Dodd et al. (38) used SCAR to recognize GV4 from other T. virens isolates.
Rep-PCR fingerprinting was reproducible and easy to assay in T. harzianum. The rep1R-I produced more polymorphic bands and detected more loci than other primers in rep-PCR. Markers that were used here mangaed to differentiate WT and mutants and efficiently established these differences with the phenotype of antagonism against fungal phytopathogens. Trombert et al. (39) used rep-PCR to distinguish UV mutation in Escherichia coli and observed that it was a suitable marker to show the effects of UV mutation in microorganisms. Afsharmanesh et al. (40) assessed the random mutagenesis by gamma radiation on Bacillus subtilis UTB1 in biocontrolling Aspergillus flavus. Eight mutants out of the 45 were selected based on different polymorphicpatterns, obtained by rep-PCR (ERIC and BOX). Of which, six mutants showed enhanced production of biosurfactants and produced more robust biofilm than the wild type UTB1. Several studies have shown that gamma ray radiation could change the enzyme activity and other antifungal metabolites (41 , 42). Ahari et al. (23) applied gamma irradiation 150 Gy.second-1 (by 0.38 rate dose) on F. solani f.sp. phaseoli and were able to induce production of nonpathogenic mutants as biocontrol agents against pathogenic isolates (F. solani f.sp. phaseoli). Here, three mutants were introduced that cauld possibly be used as effective biocontrol agents against the mentioned soil borne fungal pathogens. Further studies on enzyme assays of superior mutants, sequencing of their differential bands obtained in other molecular marker analyses are needed to provide the mechanism involved in antagonistic activity of the mutants and finally to test the biocontrol abilities of mutants in nature.